My maternal grandmother's first cousin, Dorothy, was adopted. She looked for her biological parents but did not find them in her lifetime. Dorothy passed in 2011. Dorothy was born Joann Vitiello. Her name was later changed to Dorothy Jean Martian by the parents who raised her, Catherine McQuaid Martian (AKA Aunt Kitty) and George E. Martian.
Dorothy's daughters Cathy and Terry, wanted to find their biological grandmother. They started their journey with DNA testing earlier this year they got their results. Through DNA matches, building out their family trees, Dorothy's notes and obituaries we were able to piece it all together and find Dorothy's biological mother! Dorothy's birth certificate listed Rosalie Vitiello as mother and Fred Murray as father.
We hit gold with a 3rd - 4th cousin DNA match to N.D. who shares 117 centimorgans shared across 8 DNA segments with Cathy & Terry. Thanks to the wonderful tree they had attached to their account, I was able to look up his grandparent's obituaries and discover that his grandmother's maiden name was Vitiello! I think we're on to something! We also discovered that she married Michael Belangio in 1954. Then I was able to build a mirror tree and built out the family tree collaterally. A trip to Trenton uncovered N.D.'s great grandparent's names on his grandmother's death certificate. They are the common ancestor which makes N.D. a second cousin to Cathy & Terry. He was easy enough to find on Facebook. I sent him a message.
N.D. was quick to respond to my message. He confirmed that his grandmother had a sister that went by "Ronna". He shared: "She was special. Lol. She use to rob my pennies when I was a kid while playing poker. Haha". He was unsure what cemetery she was in, but would check with family and get back to me. He also was going to look for photos of her as well.
Now that we knew she went by "Ronna" we had another name to go on and found her obituary. Unfortunately, it did not list her entombment. Another trip to Trenton and I was able to find her death notice and published obituary. The death notice was not available online and this was key to finding the cemetery.
| Death Notice |
| Obituary |
The parents matched N.D.'s grandmother's parents. This is her!
Due to Cathy's awesome google search skills, she found a book that was written by N.D.'s father. Naturally, both Terry and Cathy ordered the book. This photo was in there. Standing in the center of the back row is Ronna with her siblings and parents.
Ronna is entombed in Hollywood Memorial Park in Union, NJ. Visiting her grave revealed one extra surprise...she is with her parents.






